18世紀(jì)的“AI” - 土耳其行棋傀儡

@unvergebeneid  
Can we for a second admire the fact that the mechanism could grab a chess piece and place it accurately on the board, with very little force required? That's astonishing for the time!  
咱們能不能花點時間感嘆下——這機器能用極小力度精準(zhǔn)抓取棋子并擺放到棋盤上？這在當(dāng)時簡直驚為天人！  

@chess  
The Turk was a tease for the future, for when machine eventually would pass man.  
"土耳其行棋傀儡"其實是未來的預(yù)告，預(yù)示機器終將超越人類的時代。  

@JawRippa  
Honestly, it is impressive how a chess master would be able to reliably win in such uncomfortable conditions.  
說實話，棋手能在如此惡劣環(huán)境下穩(wěn)定獲勝，實在令人驚嘆。  

@Amonimus  
What I find more impressive is that several chessmasters have agreed to work under such uncomfortable conditions, won anyway, and took no credit.  
更讓我震驚的是，那么多棋壇高手甘愿在惡劣環(huán)境中工作，贏了比賽卻不留姓名。  

@TheUltimegaMan  
You know it’s a good trick when after it’s explained to you, you’re still impressed.  
真正的精妙魔術(shù)就是——即便知道了機關(guān)原理，你依然會被震撼到。  

@TheAmazingCowpig  
I don't know what's more impressive, the actual mechanical operation of the whole thing, or the operators/chessmasters inside managing to do their part and never being discovered while also operating the thing correctly.  
這機器本身的結(jié)構(gòu)設(shè)計，和內(nèi)部棋手既要正確操作又要完美藏匿，哪個更厲害？我選不出來。  

@Chill-Ice  
But that means technically that chess master was in like the top 1% for chess. Crazy  
按這標(biāo)準(zhǔn)，藏在機器里的棋手得是頂尖1%中的頂級高手，這也太夸張了。  

@adamb89  
Imagine being one of those two kids who climbed on the roof, actually DID see someone climb out, you actually DID know how the trick worked...and until the end of your days nobody believes you.  
想象一下：你就是那兩個爬上屋頂、親眼看到有人鉆出來的小孩，明明知道機關(guān)卻始終無人相信。  

@michelebastianini3986  
Astonishing how Wikipedia and many book I've read weren't crystal clear on the mechanism of The Turk, yet your video unveiled the mystery, amazing  
維基百科和我讀過的書都沒說清"土耳其行棋傀儡"的機制，結(jié)果你的視頻揭開了謎底，太棒了。  

@Oofof  
imagine being too good at chess that you got to get locked up inside a box just to challenge famous & smart opponents  
當(dāng)棋藝太高超時，代價就是被鎖進箱子里挑戰(zhàn)各路名人高手——這畫面太魔幻了。  

@shuban863  
Despite the fact that it was obvious that it was not a real chess machine, the clever tricks to convince the audience that it was, was really the key to this amazing invention  
雖然明眼人都知道這不是真機器，但那些讓觀眾信以為真的精巧設(shè)計，才是這項發(fā)明的精髓。  

@mh4392  
What amazes me is that none of the thousands of people that saw the machine demanded both doors to be open at the same time.  
最讓我驚訝的是，成千上萬的觀眾竟沒人要求同時打開兩扇門檢查。  

@armaan7381  
People using bots to play good chess while this robot using people for it  
現(xiàn)在人用AI下棋，而這個"機器人"卻反向操作——用真人下棋。  

@boboboz9541  
im still convinced there's a man hiding inside the ATM machine at all times.  
我現(xiàn)在還堅信ATM機里藏著個隨時待命的工作人員。  

@mitchgrove4086  
As disappointed as I am to find that nobody hundreds of years ago worked out the clockwork to nearly guarantee a win in chess, with a humanoid robot involved, I sure am impressed at the tenacity of the robot's creator in finding so many well-practiced chess-matters to crawl in that box and operate it in such a complex manor!  
雖然有點失望——幾百年前沒人發(fā)明確保贏棋的發(fā)條機器人，但發(fā)明者能找到那么多訓(xùn)練有素的棋手蜷縮在箱內(nèi)操作，這種毅力真讓人佩服。  

@rasultalishinskiy5578  
I gotta admit, even thou I i was sure it's not a pure machine, its mechanical abilities are still very astonishing.  
雖然早猜到不是純機械，但它的機械構(gòu)造依然令人驚嘆。  

@notoriousbigmoai1125  
It's still impressive that the hidden person managed to beat all the good chess players while sitting in a very cramped and stuffy position. This wouldn't be possible without a highly skilled and patient individual.  
藏在憋屈箱子里還能擊敗頂尖棋手，這得需要多么高超的棋藝和驚人的耐心啊。  

@bosco7837  
The Turk came right before what is universally considered the Golden Age of magic in Europe. It cleverly uses a lot of principles of modern stage magic. The way the trunk appears to be empty but isn't, for example. No wonder it caused such a stir at the time, it's a great illusion.  
"土耳其行棋傀儡"誕生于歐洲魔術(shù)黃金時代前夕，運用了現(xiàn)代舞臺魔術(shù)原理——比如看似空箱實則藏人，難怪當(dāng)時引起轟動。  

@999benhonda  
Dang...the board only showed the chess master when pieces had been moved, the chess master had to be able to track which pieces were moved...with only candle light in a cramped space.  
天...棋盤只在棋子移動時顯示棋局，棋手得在狹窄空間里僅靠燭光追蹤每個棋子的動向。  

@vampirecount3880  
What I find most incredible about Turk's concept is that someone, in the 1700s, already thought about the possibility of creating a machine capable of thinking (playing chess). Even if it was an illusion, it amazes me that people so long ago were already able to consider the concept of AI, and already knew that one day, machines would do anything.  
最讓我震撼的是，18世紀(jì)就有人構(gòu)思會下棋的機器。即便是騙局，也說明當(dāng)時人們已在設(shè)想AI概念，預(yù)言機器終將無所不能。  

@KelvinDethoften  
"We're losing to a mechanical chess robot, what do we do?"  
"There's nothing we can do."  
"我們被機械棋手打敗了，怎么辦？"  
"躺平吧，沒救了。"  

@TheeRandomGuy  
My first instinct was a series of mirrors similar to the Peppers Ghost illusion hiding a person. Such a smart workaround with the candlelight through the machine maneuver  
我第一反應(yīng)是用了類似"佩珀爾幻影"的鏡面裝置藏人，沒想到用燭光配合機械結(jié)構(gòu)，這招真聰明。  

@FallSkyX  
It's astonishing how none of the chess masters inside the Turk ever made a mistake while switching positions in such a confined space. Although it was evident that something was definitely up, I initially thought it might be remotely controlled by a chess master using some ingenious mechanism. However, upon realizing the Turk was from the 1700s and 1800s, and that the first instance of wireless communication wasn't until 1849, it made sense that wasn't the case.  
藏在箱內(nèi)的棋手在狹小空間換位時居然零失誤，這很驚人。雖然早覺得有貓膩，但原以為是遠程操控，后來想起無線通信1849年才出現(xiàn)，才明白不可能。  

@cccyanide3034  
As other commenters pointed out, it was kind of expected that the machine was human-operated. There simply was no way to store this amount of information on physical storage at the time.  
就像其他評論說的，當(dāng)時科技水平下，純機械存儲海量棋局數(shù)據(jù)根本不現(xiàn)實，人工操作是必然。  

@viccypress6292  
Surely someone yelled "now leave the damn box open! And play"  
Awesome breakdown! Such genius minds.  
肯定有人喊過"把該死的箱子開著下棋！"，這解析太棒了！天才設(shè)計！  

@cinnamonflavord  
Even though it's not a robot, it's still impressive for the person inside the box to still beat all of those famous people  
雖不是真機器人，但箱中人能擊敗那么多名人已足夠驚人。  

@Tkonk  
I definitely would have thought it was controlled by a person but I never would have figured out how they were folded into it. Great visualizations as always.  
我早猜到是真人操控，但完全想不出怎么塞進去的。演示動畫一如既往地棒。  

@Demphure  
As soon as it specified that the showman would open one door, close it, and then open the next, I knew there was someone inside that just moved around  
當(dāng)聽說表演者輪流開關(guān)兩扇門時，我立刻明白里面藏著會移動的人。  

@elhafydymohamed4078  
To be able to play well even from inside a box with inconvenient controls is amazing  
在操控不便的箱子里還能下得一手好棋，這水平絕了。  

@UmVtCg  
Finally, an animated video which shows the inner working of this magicians chess trick. But where did the smoke and fumes of the candle inside go?  
終于有動畫展示這個魔術(shù)棋局的內(nèi)部構(gòu)造了！但箱內(nèi)蠟燭的煙霧怎么處理的？  

@Domus_Maximus  
I'm sure I'd seen another video on The Turk previously, but this was really done and very very well presented. Great video!  
雖然以前看過相關(guān)視頻，但這個講解得既專業(yè)又清晰，太棒了！  

@Paulitica  
Its incredible that 300 years ago we thought a machine was a fake just because it was impossible to beat human intelligence, nowadays we would be surprised of humans beating machines...  
三百年前因機器無法戰(zhàn)勝人類而認定是騙局，現(xiàn)在人類贏機器反而成了新聞，真魔幻。  

@RCmies  
There's no way that it didnt drop pieces or place them incorrectly sometimes. But if it didn't then this is an amazing design.  
棋子肯定有掉錯位置的時候吧？要是真沒出過錯，這設(shè)計就太神了。  

@IlayKimhi  
I thought that the player opposing the machine is cooperating with the machine operator and just playing a set of known moves agreed upon before the show. Then, the operator somehow codes a sequence of moves into the Turk's arm with a complicated mechanism. That would probably be too complicated tho :D  
我還以為是挑戰(zhàn)者與操作者串通，提前記好棋步，再用復(fù)雜機械編碼到機械臂上——不過這樣確實太復(fù)雜了。  

@HritwRaje  
How long would a session usually last? Considering that the hidden chess masters were human and would require (probably multiple) candles to light up the insides, and also stay put until the Turk was in a safehouse before crawling out for a restroom break, is astonishing.  
一局要下多久？考慮到棋手需要多支蠟燭照明，還要憋到機器移至安全屋才能上廁所，這耐力絕了。  

@matiszkielet  
The magnet mechanism is so clever!  
磁鐵機關(guān)設(shè)計得太巧妙了！  

@Woowosh  
Poor the brilliant chest master inside the machine, which maybe would never get credit in the history  
藏在機器里的天才棋手太慘了，可能永遠得不到歷史認可。  

@НикитаВоронин-х8ю  
Imagine being a man in the machine and trying not to sneeze  
想象下箱子里的人拼命憋噴嚏的樣子  

@guppygb6078  
Audience member - "Open both doors at the same time"  
觀眾："兩扇門同時打開看看"  

@SocksAndSalami  
The technology behind this was INSANELY ahead of its time  
這項技術(shù)在當(dāng)時簡直是跨時代的存在  

@TechnoThornYT  
I can’t believe such intricate mechanisms existed back then! I had a suspicion that there was an operator inside the Turk, but didn’t know how it would fit in the box.  
難以置信當(dāng)時就有這么精密的機械！雖然懷疑有操作者，但完全想不出怎么塞進箱子。  

@petervarga2399  
Amazing animations and a fascinating story. It is very impressive how everyone involved kept the secret.  
精彩的動畫和引人入勝的故事，所有參與者能守住秘密這點更讓人佩服。

@shaeisgae8952  
I appreciate the thumbnail having the answer to the explanation as well as having timestamps to skip ahead, im interested enough to watch the whole thing though this is rlly interesting  
感謝視頻封面既標(biāo)注了答案又有進度條提示，雖然我對整個內(nèi)容很感興趣會全部看完，但這確實設(shè)計得很貼心。

@robertbrandywine  
I'm surprised no magicians looked at it and didn't figure it out immediately. The first suspicious thing was that both sides weren't opened at the same time.  
魔術(shù)師們居然沒有立刻看穿機關(guān)，這讓我很驚訝。最可疑的破綻就是他們從不同時打開機器兩側(cè)的門。

@dead_space.  
amazing! I always get invested into these videos after a long day it’s always refreshing to see how stuff from yesterday is explained and shown today.  
太棒了！結(jié)束漫長工作后看這種揭秘視頻特別解壓，用現(xiàn)代技術(shù)重現(xiàn)歷史謎團的感覺真奇妙。

@Giorgio_2466  
Although I already knew the story, you kept me engaged all throughout the video with your amazing storytelling!  
雖然早知道這個故事，但你充滿感染力的敘事還是讓我全程沉浸其中。

@jonahwoodward503  
I doubted that it was mechanical, but then a little disappointed that the answer was kind of expected. I wondered if it would be some sort of mechanical computer with pressure plates on the board, but the dangling magnets were a neat idea.  
我曾懷疑是純機械結(jié)構(gòu)，但真相有點平淡反而讓人失望。原本期待棋盤下有壓力板組成的機械計算機，不過吊掛磁鐵的設(shè)計確實巧妙。

@keithknight7861  
Imagine being in that box and beating a king and hearing throw this whole fucking box in the fire  
想象一下：你躲在箱子里贏了個國王，結(jié)果聽見對方怒吼"把這該死的箱子扔進火里！"

@bobpourri9647  
Poster....please read Poe's essay on the machine. He DID NOT simply believe the dummy body held an individual: His writing goes to great length to explain how the cabinet was occupied by the manipulator, and by a series of bends & twists deceived the inspecting public during a showing, much as shown at 6:54 .  
建議UP主讀讀愛倫坡的論文。他并非簡單認為人藏在假人里，而是詳細描述了操作者如何利用箱體彎折結(jié)構(gòu)騙過觀眾，和視頻6:54展示的機關(guān)如出一轍。

@RotoruaBoysHighSchool  
Awesome video man! This was very well explained and detailed. Honestly, I wasn't in any shape or form sure how he could see underneath the obxts. But because of this video, You have helped out a ton with the matter. As said before, awesome video. I am not even sure how you only got less than a million subscribers.  
超棒的視頻！講解清晰細節(jié)到位，之前完全想不通棋手怎么觀察棋盤，現(xiàn)在豁然開朗。說真的，這么優(yōu)質(zhì)的頻道訂閱量不過百萬沒天理。

@drewhailstones4106  
This is quite fascinating, i have watched multiple videos on the Chess player Turk but i love how you explain it, simply and without fluff, but you get the point across. Also great voice. PS. Could you in the future do a video on Hugo Cabret's Automaton? (if you can)  
雖然看過很多土耳其行棋傀儡的視頻，但你的解說干凈利落直擊重點，聲音也超有魅力。順便求做雨果的《造夢的雨果》里那個機械人解析！

@augustinf  
How on earth has no chess player ever coughed, sneezed, grunted or made any slight noise in 70 years? They were a few centimeters below their opponents. There is no way no one did not feel that human presence  
整整70年藏在箱子里的大活人怎么可能從不打噴嚏咳嗽？對手就坐在幾厘米上方，絕對能察覺到動靜啊！

@jeffyoung60  
As a young teenager I recall reading the story about the robot Turk chess player in a book that I think was, Ripley's Believe It or Not. The book clearly stated a chess master had been hired to secrete himself inside the large base of the ersatz autonomotan. The one difference I seem to recall is that the book claimed the human chess master was able to put his hand and arm into the moving right arm of the robot and thus move it about as if it were a real mechanical arm.  
我年輕時在《信不信由你》里讀到過這個故事。書里說棋手藏在底座，還能把手伸進機械臂操控——這和視頻里的磁鐵操控方式不太一樣。

@KaranKumar-do9wb  
This story deserves a Movie man .  
這傳奇故事絕對夠拍部電影了！

@mattiaseven5869  
This is one of the most interesting videos I see in the last 5 years, i am not joking.  
認真說，這是我五年來看過最有趣的視頻。

@dotWcom  
I thought that a person was there under the skin of the turk  
我一直以為操作者藏在那個土耳其人偶的軀干里。

@kinghenry100  
And the entire plan relied on that one candle…  
整個機關(guān)居然全靠一根蠟燭照明？

@maxrabiega592  
Amazing engineering this is. Would’ve been really cool if this was around.  
精妙的工程設(shè)計！真希望這個裝置能保存至今。

@Theoneintheone  
Amazing content, I was hooked onto the details outflow right from the start till the end. Really nice!.  
超棒的內(nèi)容！從開場到結(jié)尾每個細節(jié)都引人入勝。

@liemaze  
Awesome video! Loved how you broke down the robot chess player scam. The historical context and your storytelling made it super interesting and easy to follow. Great job with the research too.  
超贊！拆解騙局的過程配合歷史背景變得超有趣，考證也很嚴(yán)謹。

@halitosmanyurdakul6266  
Imagine that you are a chess master, but no one knows you because you are inside a machine.  
想象你是個絕世棋手，卻因藏在機器里而無人知曉。

@Lofi_Boy0107  
I really like Science behind mechanical things especially those things invented in past history like Turk, and this is one of your best video!  
超愛這種機械原理揭秘，尤其是歷史發(fā)明！這期是你最佳作品之一。

@lolegaia  
The operator be like the smartest chessmater ever existed.  
藏在里面的棋手堪稱史上最強工具人。

@Youtubedictatorship  
Back in the day when the news outlets were actually worried about journalistic integrity.  
那個年代的媒體居然還關(guān)心新聞?wù)鎸嵭浴?br />
@Humtog  
Excellent video! Remarkable storytelling and animation as always. I feel that since it's secrets were revealed years after it was destroyed in the fire, it might be inaccurate or simplistic. For example, precise gripping of the pieces and moving it to the new location would have required something more complicated than what was shown. The precision required to move without touching any other piece is the hard part. Secondly, I imagine there would be more levers to move the head and the other hand. Thirdly, that candle presented a risk of light leakage through any of the panels or tiny holes. And if it is well sealed, it requires oxygen to burn. So, some venting is required. Overall impressed it was able to keep the secret despite having so many people involved over the 90 years. Suggestion - Titling this as a "The Robot Chess Player Scam" is doing a dis-service to this masterpiece. Magic is not scam. Also, revealing the secret in the thumbnail showing a man inside is also not a good idea. A better title would be "Chess playing Robot of 1700s" And thumbnail showing the robot with words "Beats champions"  
精彩視頻！但我覺得機關(guān)可能比展示的更復(fù)雜，例如精準(zhǔn)移動棋子需要更精密的設(shè)計，燭光也可能從縫隙泄露。最震撼的是近百年來這么多人保守秘密。建議標(biāo)題別用"騙局"這個詞，畢竟魔術(shù)不是詐騙，封面劇透也欠妥，改成"18世紀(jì)象棋機器人"更好。

@raggedclawstarcraft6562  
Damn I were hoping it was a mechanical magnet-based analogue computer.  
淦！我還以為是用磁鐵做的模擬計算機呢。

@Handles_AreStupid  
If you knew how the machine worked, you could hypothetically defeat the chess master by being indecisive and picking and dropping random pieces. You'd cause enough confusion that he would lose track of which piece is where if you did it correctly.  
知道機關(guān)原理的話，可以通過反復(fù)拿起放下棋子擾亂棋手記憶，這樣就能打敗他。

@tal_laal  
Nice video! I legit thought the guy who made the machine was using magnets to move the chess pieces around somehow standing away from the machine taking inspiration from the performance in the beginning about magnets.  
好視頻！開場磁鐵表演讓我誤以為發(fā)明者是遠程用磁鐵操控棋子。

@mozartpiano23  
Could you imagine being those kids and no one believes you saw someone climb out  
那些目擊操作者爬出來的孩子，得多郁悶沒人相信他們啊！

@chtey1234  
Napoleon Bonaparte was chess master!?!?!?!?!?! Wow a emperor, master of artillery, commander and chess master nice  
拿破侖居然是象棋大師？！又是皇帝又是炮兵專家還懂下棋，這人設(shè)太完美了吧！

@Daniel4646  
A trick which baffled the world for nearly a century. The longest-lasting show illusion ever.  
騙了全世界近一個世紀(jì)的魔術(shù)，史上最持久的舞臺幻術(shù)。

@MikeLikesGamesalot  
Robots use humans!  
humans use robots!  
1769年：機器人使用人類（作為核心）！  
2024年：人類使用機器人！  

@techny3000  
Honestly I would've thought it had something to do with the floor below the turk  
some doors and a sliding chair sounds far more simple lol  
說實話，我之前一直以為玄機在土耳其棋手下方的地板里，結(jié)果只是幾扇門加一把滑動椅子？這也太簡單了吧。  

@leventkucukaslan4238  
Even if the Ottomans could not get into Vienna,  
They could conquer the entire Empire of Chess…  
就算奧斯曼帝國當(dāng)年沒能攻下維也納，至少他們征服了整個國際象棋帝國啊……  

@everyonee.  
A man putting a lot of effort inside the machine and still manage to beat almost all of his opponents is much more impressive than the machine itself.  
比起機器本身，更讓我佩服的是里面的人——他縮在狹小空間里費盡心思，居然還能打敗幾乎所有對手。  

@TheBigdan217  
This is a lie, it was real magic  
騙人！這分明是真正的魔法。  

@Essela_5056  
The fact that the turk isnt even a turk  
最搞笑的是，所謂的“土耳其棋手”壓根不是土耳其人。  

@Larry  
I'm surprised the operator didn't use a periscope like mirror system to see the chessboard above.  
我挺驚訝操作員居然沒用潛望鏡式的鏡子系統(tǒng)來觀察上方棋盤。  

@anmoljoshi5705  
The story of the Turk is such a captivating blend of history, engineering, and illusion. I can't believe it fooled people for almost 90 years! Great video!  
土耳其棋手的故事完美融合了歷史、工程學(xué)和騙術(shù)，太抓人了！難以想象它居然能忽悠世人近90年！視頻做得很棒！  

@kelf114  
Leaving a lit candle inside after closing the doors seems like it would be a dead giveaway.  
關(guān)門后還留根點燃的蠟燭在里面，這操作難道不會露餡嗎？  

@milesabsher6046  
I thought the person would be in the larger more empty compartment but the way they actually did it was very interesting! Great part of history right there.  
我以為人會藏在更寬敞的隔層里，沒想到實際設(shè)計更有趣！這段歷史真了不起。  

@tuckervining5673  
At first i thought there was someone in there but then i was stumped when he did the demonstration of how nobody is in there. also mad respect for the operator that must've been uncomfortable  
起初我也覺得里面藏了人，但看到展示空箱子的環(huán)節(jié)就懵了。不過還是佩服操作員——縮在里面肯定難受死了。  

@pbdropshot5369  
And every chess master operator never let out a single fart during the game, well played.  
所有棋手操作員居然都能忍住不在對局中放屁，這定力我給滿分。  

@bhaaratsharma6023  
Even if there was a man sitting beneath the table top, I'm still very impressed at the design of this contraption  
就算桌下真藏了人，這機器的設(shè)計本身也夠讓我震驚了。  

@scott4868  
The secret seems like it’s even more unbelievable than any of the other theories. It’s just so thorough and seemingly over engineered. Like when you get to the end of a mystery tv show and they just give an explanation no one would ever guess.  
說實話，真正的秘密比任何陰謀論都離譜——設(shè)計得過于精密，簡直像懸疑劇結(jié)局硬塞個沒人猜得到的解釋。  

@theseageek  
The most impressive thing about this is the accuracy and dexterity of the mechanism that allowed for picking up the chess pieces and placing them on the board accurately. This reminds me of those robotic arms the surgeons today use for very delicate operation.  
最牛的是機械裝置抓取棋子的精準(zhǔn)度，簡直像現(xiàn)代外科手術(shù)用的機械臂一樣靈活。  

@gabrielho1874  
Even as a machine that is not self-moving, the mechanism for moving and guiding the pieced without knocking the others is really impressive  
盡管不是全自動機器，但能在移動棋子時不碰倒其他棋子，這機制已經(jīng)夠驚艷了。  

@Random_0012  
Wow, I never knew the Mechanical Turk was this complex! It's amazing how they kept the secret for so long. Great video!  
哇，我之前完全不知道機械土耳其棋手這么復(fù)雜！他們居然能保密這么久，太厲害了！視頻超棒！  

@coffeebot3000  
I'd heard about this many times was always interested how it works. Your video made it so clear. Very cool. Thank you.  
以前聽過很多次這玩意兒，但一直好奇原理。你的視頻講得超清楚，太酷了！感謝！  

@kingbrucelee4977  
I wasn't sure how the chessmaster knew all this moves that opponents did. I thought there's an additional chessboard upside down that in some unexplainable way behave like that chessboard from the top, but it turned out there are wires holding magnets. Fascinating  
我之前想不通棋手怎么知道對手的每一步，還以為是上下顛倒的鏡像棋盤，結(jié)果居然是磁鐵加導(dǎo)線？太有意思了！  

@KuyaArbee  
damn impressive! that the CHESS MASTER couldn't cough... sneeze etc  
真絕了！那些棋手居然能忍住不咳嗽、不打噴嚏……  

@QuestanableClue  
Personally I also thought that it was operated by a human, but I didn't think about the fake  and shifting floors. For a technology this old, this is beyond crazy i am really impressed by the machinery and the actually person playing the chess hidden inside the contraption. Great Video!  
我也猜過里面是人，但沒想到還有假地板和滑動結(jié)構(gòu)。以當(dāng)年的技術(shù)水平，這設(shè)計簡直瘋狂！機器和藏身其中的棋手都讓我佩服得五體投地！視頻超棒！  

@thatoneguyeveryoneknows3440  
Has anyone ever burned a candle in a small space? That part doesn't make sence?  
誰試過在小空間里點蠟燭??？這部分設(shè)定不合理吧？  

@YtubeUserr  
Imagine the Chess Master inside sneezed or farted? He had real control to pull this off without being discovered.  
要是里面的棋手突然打個噴嚏或放屁怎么辦？這自制力簡直非人類。  

@user-gd7wr4cx4l  
It's always a secret compartment, but I never would have guessed how the chess pieces were moved. So so cool  
雖然知道肯定有暗格，但棋子移動的方式完全出乎意料！酷斃了！  

@U-V-F  
Imagine if the chess master inside had to pee so bad but had to hold it while the player took his time thinking of the next moves.  
想象一下，棋手憋尿憋到爆炸，對手卻還在慢悠悠思考下一步……  

@imjody  
That's wild. This guy basically playing 4D chess against people just playing normal chess. So much more stress and skill necessary to be able to run this machine, keep track of where every piece was picked up from and placed, and still win.  
太狂了！這家伙簡直是在用多線程思考對戰(zhàn)普通玩家，不僅要操控機器，還得記住每顆棋子的移動軌跡，壓力山大還能贏，實力逆天！  

@eletere-jx1vg  
These animations are great! I have no idea how someone crafted such a high technologically advanced obxt at this time.  
動畫做得超棒！完全想不通當(dāng)時的人是怎么造出這種高科技玩意兒的。  

@NoriMori1992  
The precision engineering this thing would have required in order to work so well is so insane that I'm almost more impressed by that than if it were an actual robot.  
這機器需要的精密工程學(xué)簡直變態(tài)，我甚至覺得比真機器人還震撼。  

@GWMJRSmith  
You would still have to remember what piece was where. Knowing what piece was where after ten moves is within itself insane. And, much more important than just knowing a piece is on the spot.  
不僅要記住棋子位置，還得清楚走了十步后每個格子上是什么棋子，這難度比單純知道位置高多了。  

@monsoon1234567890  
Literally every single genius back in the day - "That big empty space in the middle must surely be for storage."  
當(dāng)年的天才們看到中間空蕩蕩的區(qū)域，肯定都心想：“這地方絕對用來儲物！”  

@mevsol2447  
All that intellect and nobody thought to open both doors at once.  
一群聰明人居然沒一個想到同時打開兩扇門？  

@sickboy9902  
In a way, the existence of this invention coupled with the honesty and skill of the operators and the longevity of the secret itself is actually more impressive than an computer's ability to play chess  
某種意義上，這發(fā)明本身、操作員的誠信與技術(shù)，加上秘密能守這么久，比電腦下棋的能力更讓人震撼。  

@NGUYENHOANGLONG-2012  
WOW, the brilliancy of the machine is INSANE must've taken the inventor a long time to think of a design like that!  
哇！這機器的設(shè)計絕了！發(fā)明者肯定絞盡腦汁才想出這種結(jié)構(gòu)！  

@Selfg12  
Honestly though... It's even MORE impressive for him to win games like that. He has to memorize which piece is where, as the magnet doesn't tell him if it's a knight, pawn, bishop, or queen on that square.  
說真的，這樣還能贏棋更厲害！畢竟磁鐵不會告訴他格子上是騎士、兵、主教還是皇后。  

@daverist1234  
They say ai would replace us, but WE replaced the ai with us.  
都說AI會取代人類，結(jié)果我們先用人類取代了AI。  

@jayplash24  
the chess masters inside the machine were  beasts, being in such a small compartment, replicating their opponents moves perfectly (one screw up of replicating the move and its literally over for the chess master), and keeping the secret hidden too  
機器里的棋手都是狠人！縮在小隔間里完美復(fù)刻對手每一步（錯一步就完蛋），還能守住秘密！